THE CRUNCH
Italy's data protection regulator, the Garante, has fined Meta 805 million euros, about $886 million, saying Facebook accessed Android users' photos and videos without their specific consent. Announced on Saturday, it is one of the largest fines the regulator has ever issued.
The case centres on the "camera roll" suggestions option Facebook launched in 2023, which the regulator alleges was used to browse users' photo galleries and recommend posts they could enhance with personal photos and videos. Related metadata was accessed too, according to the Garante.
The investigation found Meta asked for access through a single permission that applies across the entire app and covers multiple features with different requirements, preceded by a notice that did not make clear users were consenting to camera roll suggestions. The regulator also alleged the feature was on by default. In the Garante's view, a full permission lets an app reach the entire photo library, usually permanently, without users or regulators being able to verify what is actually used.
Meta argued the Garante lacked jurisdiction, a claim the regulator dismissed. A Meta spokesperson told other news outlets that the company strongly disagrees with the decision and plans to appeal what it called the disproportionate fine amount. The size reflects roughly 20 million affected Italian Android users, the long period of the violation and Meta's lack of cooperation during the probe, the regulator said.
Alongside the fine, Meta has 60 days to make changes, including seeking consent through a request separate and specific to the feature, explaining clearly what it is for, and disabling the option by default. The penalty lands as Meta faces mounting privacy scrutiny abroad; in October a US court fined the company $25 billion for deceiving consumers about how it uses their data.


