THE CRUNCH
Sony has seen off a £2 billion UK class action that accused it of charging "excessive and unfair" prices on the PlayStation Store. London's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the case on Tuesday, 17 November, after a 30-day trial, rejecting the claim that PlayStation buyers were trapped in a closed ecosystem.
The case was brought in 2022 by consumer advocate Alex Neill on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners. It argued that Sony's control of the store let it take a 30% cut of every digital sale, and that games would have been roughly 20% cheaper in a more open market. Had it succeeded, eligible players could have received about £162 each.
The tribunal was not persuaded. It ruled that the market definitions behind the claim were "unsafe" and that Sony competes in a wider "systems market" alongside Xbox, Nintendo and PC. It found "strong evidence of a willingness of consumers to switch consoles" if prices rose, and no evidence that allowing third-party storefronts would actually have lowered PlayStation Store prices.
There is a wrinkle in the reasoning, though. The tribunal leaned partly on physical copies and rival consoles as alternatives, yet Sony plans to phase out physical game sales by January 2028. The case also never examined whether players truly own their digital games, an argument Sony's own lawyers have conceded they do not.
This is not the end of the road for such claims. Sony faces a similar suit in the Netherlands over the so-called "Sony tax", and the same UK tribunal ruled against Apple last year in an App Store case with a strikingly similar 30% cut at its heart.


